Madeline Henderson "It worked out in the best way possible because Trisha Paytas happened to be in Chicago that night," Natalie tells PEOPLE. "I waited until a few days before to try to make it ...

Noah Galvin Fixes Husband Ben Platt's Hair in Adorable Red Carpet Moment at Broadway Premiere 'Fearless' Trisha Paytas Makes Her Broadway Debut with Special Guests Rachel Zegler, Sutton Foster and ...