Miracle Whip and mayo from Kraft, Kewpie, Duke's, Hellmann's — on their own and in chicken salad to find the best.

When I was a kid, growing up in Ohio, we had two separate jars in the fridge that looked pretty similar: Hellmann's ...

Hellmann's is usually my go-to mayo, but it ended up in the middle of the ranking for me. I liked Giant's store-brand mayo, Kraft Real Mayo, and the controversial Miracle Whip most of all.