In-universe, the asterisk in Thunderbolts* flags that the title is unofficial—only after CIA director Valentina Allegra de Fontaine’s press conference does the team earn the “New Avengers” badge. Fans noted that the term “Old Avengers” spoiled the twist that Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson contests the new team’s right to the Avengers mantle.

And now, Robert Downey Jr. may have accidentally joined the Spoiler Squad. Fans believe Robert Downey Jr. may have spoiled Thunderbolts* with one seemingly innocent Instagram caption: “Just wow!!! Dinner and a show with the Old Avengers.

While I won’t be sharing any spoilers for the latest MCU tale here, what isn’t a spoiler is that it was officially announced last month that many of Thunderbolts*’s starring characters will be back for next year’s Avengers: Doomsday.