Dave proposed to his girlfriend, Lexi, via caricature art at the Florida State Fair on Feb. 16. 'I did not think it was going to happen at the fair the way it happened,' Lexi tells PEOPLE.

Florida — sat down next to each other and smiled for artist Damion Dunn, who would create a caricature portrait of them. Based on a video recently posted by Dunn on TikTok, Instagram and YouTube ...