The judge in the high-profile murder case declared a mistrial after an Orange County jury could not reach a unanimous verdict after a week of deliberation.

Update: The judge declared a mistrial in the case against Edward Holley on Wednesday morning. GOSHEN — With the judge apparently on the verge of declaring a mistrial in the Edward V.

GOSHEN - A man who was in the medical unit at the Orange County jail at the same time as Edward Holley in spring 2023 testified Thursday in court that Holley confessed to others at the jail he had ...

Police arrested Edward Holley, McDonald's former boyfriend, in 2023 and charged him with second-degree murder. If convicted, Holley faces up to 25 years to life in prison. GOSHEN - The prosecution ...

Holley is accused of bludgeoning McDonald, his ex-girlfriend, to death in 2003 in the Town of Walkill in a rageful attack motivated by jealousy and money. The Wawayanda man and longtime suspect ...